Jernigan's - Arbiters of Fine Taste


Virtual Tour

















Sober Musings

USGA RULE OF THE WEEK

  • SOBER MUSINGS HOME
  • ARTICLE REPRINTS
  • WEEK 5 —RULE 20

    Whenever a player deviates, by choice or requirement, from the concept of "play the ball as it lies," he employs Rule 20.

    The most common and simple example of the use of Rule 20 is the player who lifts his ball from the putting green. The requirement, in Rule 16-1b, that the lifted ball be replaced leads the player to Rule 20-1 and its specification that the position of the ball be marked before the ball is lifted. Additionally, the Note to Rule 20-1 describes the recommended method of marking the position of the ball.

    From that simple start, Rule 20 picks up the pace in Rules 20-2a and 20-2b where the following topics are discussed:
    • Who must drop the ball (the player himself)
    • How the ball must be dropped (from shoulder height while the player stands erect)
    • The criteria that must be met for the drop to be acceptable:
      • that the ball first strike a part of the course where the player was required to drop it
      • that the dropped ball must not strike the player, his partner, or their caddies or equipment
    If the ball has been dropped properly (i.e., meeting the requirements of Rules 20-2a and 20-2b), a further assessment must be made based on where the dropped ball has come to rest. Rule 20-2c lists the 7 reasons why a ball that has been dropped in the proper manner and location must be re-dropped. Further, Rule 20-2c explains that the player will only re-drop a ball one time due to Rule 20-2c and that if the re-dropped ball comes to rest such that one of those 7 reasons applies, the player must place the ball at the spot where the re-dropped ball first struck the course when it was dropped.

    The pace continues with Rule 20-3 explaining the requirements regarding balls that are to be placed (on some spot) or replaced (i.e. returned to the spot from which they were lifted or moved). Like Rule 20-2, Rule 20-3 explains:
    • Who may place a ball (the player or his partner)
    • Who may replace a ball (the player, his partner, or the person who lifted or moved the ball)
    • How a ball is placed or replaced when:
      • the original lie has been altered
      • the original location is not known
      • a placed ball will not remain on the spot on which it is placed
    If meeting the requirements contained in Rules 20-2 and 20-3 have you worried, take heart, when we get to Rule 20-6 we will see that there is an opportunity to correct our errors.

    Now that the player has dropped or placed his ball, Rule 20-4 reminds him that this dropped or placed ball is his ball in play. Note that this straightforward reminder applies equally to dropped balls that meet all of the requirements of Rule 20-2 and those that must be re-dropped under any part of that Rule. Likewise, the ball that was lifted from the putting green, under Rule 16-1b, in the second paragraph above is again in play when it is replaced even if the coin or similar object marking its position remains behind the replaced ball.

    Occasionally (hopefully, rarely), a player will be required to play his next stroke from the spot of his previous stroke. Rule 20-5 explains how the player does so.

    Prior to making a stroke with the ball that has been put into (or back into) play by dropping or placing it, the player has one last chance to correct any errors associated with putting the ball into play. Rule 20-6 allows the player to lift a ball that was improperly substituted (e.g. the player replaced a different ball on the putting green), or was dropped or placed in a wrong place or in a manner contrary to the Rules to be lifted without penalty. The player may then proceed correctly.

    Finally, Rule 20 concludes with Rule 20-7 and the penalties for playing from a wrong place in match play and stroke play. The player is considered to have played from a wrong place if: play is not permitted from the part of the course where the ball was played (e.g. from a wrong putting green), or if the player was required to re-drop the ball or to replace a moved ball and failed to do so before making his next stroke.

    In match play, the penalty for playing from a wrong place is quick and easy: loss of hole.

    In stroke play, the penalty gets more complicated. The player incurs a two-stroke penalty and will complete play of the hole with the ball played from a wrong place. However, if the player commits a serious breach of Rule 20-7c (i.e. gains a significant advantage in the view of the Committee) by playing from a wrong place, then the player is required to correct his serious breach and report this correction to the Committee.

    Reprinted with permission from the USGA.
    Two cigars on top of each other reveal an obsession or a brutality of the soul - Eugene Marsan
    Copyright 2006, Jernigan's Village, All Rights Reserved